Editor’s Note: Most of this review was taken from our Xbox 360 review of the game. Some edits have been made in regards to performance on the Wii U and the Wii U difference.
Ok, wait just a second here. You expect me to play a Splinter Cell game where Sam Fisher isn’t played by Michael Ironside? Yeah, that’s not going to happen.
Those were the immediate thoughts that ran through my head when it was announced that Mr. Ironside felt like he was too old to keep up as Splinter Cell’s main protagonist in Blacklist the newest game in this storied franchise. In my eyes it was like replacing the lead singer of a well-known band. We know that often times that scenario just doesn’t work out. I mean let’s be serious for a second, who actually likes Sammy Hagar before David Lee Roth? NOBODY, that’s who. Kids, if you don’t know who I’m talking about feel free to fire up Wikipedia. In spite of my initial reaction I’m happy to report that my fears were quite easily laid to rest once I got my hands on the game. I’ll admit that this new Sam Fisher almost made the game feel like a different title for a time but once I got further into the story everything fell right into place regardless of Eric Johnson (the new Sam) delivering what most would say to be a very different version of our hero (or anti-hero if you prefer).
In Blacklist Sam and his team are out to stop a group of would be terrorists calling themselves the Engineers. They are carrying out a list of attacks on America that they have dubbed the Blacklist and it’s up to you to step into Sam’s shoes and stop them. In a new move for the series your team sets up base in the Paladin, a giant military grade airplane that serves as your headquarters. It’s great in that it gives you a place to talk to your team and is also upgradeable to provide you with better intel on the ground as you advance. My best comparison would be a low rent version of the Normandy in the Mass Effect series. It’s not nearly as in depth but provides a very similar feeling. Without giving too much away in regards to the story I have to admit that some of the tactics used by Fisher and some of the decisions you’re forced to make as a player really blur the lines between being the good guy and essentially being a bit of a goon yourself. I can see why the development team chose to go the direction they did and if anything it’s really reflective of a lot of things we’re seeing in the news currently but I can also say that I was uncomfortable at times with making the decisions I did. I’m a hopeless good guy so choosing torture is never an option for me, even in a game. Yes, I know I’m a pansy, let’s move on.
Aside from your main story missions you have a wealth of side missions available to you courtesy of your companions on board Paladin. There are 4 different groups of side missions each orchestrated by a different companion. One of them is co-op specific while others are solo with a co-op option should you choose it. It’s a great way to play the game with a friend. Add in the metagame ‘Gone Dark’, which is a kind of boring map search game, and the Spies vs Mercs multiplayer game and you have a lot of options for gameplay.
Speaking of Spies vs Mercs it is a 2v2 (Classic) or 4v4 (Blacklist) MP game where you play as either the Spies trying to hack a run of computer terminals or the first-person style Mercs trying to hunt them down. There’s also Extraction mode which tasks the Mercs to capture a briefcase from defending Spies, Team DeathMatch which is about as self-explanatory as it can get, and Uplink Control which has teams take different control points on the map. Each option is fun and there’s no denying that the in-game tension is much more palpable when up against a human opponent rather than a game’s AI. It should provide many more hours on to a game that already gives the player a lot of content to wade through.
Many Splinter Cell aficionados were quite dismayed at what turned out to be a very action heavy game in Splinter Cell: Conviction. Ubisoft quite clearly heard their pleas and the stealth action that they know and love is back. That being said so is the action driven style of Conviction should you choose to play that way. You can choose to stick to the shadows never leaving a trace that you were even there or barrel in with guns blazing and grenades flying to tear your enemies limb from limb. If the team at Ubisoft were trying to pull off the amazing feat of keeping everyone happy they came very close in their execution. Depending on how you choose to play through each level you get scored on your play style in three categories: Ghost (non-lethal stealth), Panther (lethal stealth), and Assault (hey look at me I’m killing some motherf*ckers up in here!). Like in many games of this generation that score is of course compared to all of your friends and thus it gives you reason to replay missions in order to beat style scores as well as make speed runs and other fun activities. Personally that type of replay value is huge for me because there’s nothing I love more than sending a message to a friend saying ‘YOU SUCK, I BEAT YOU.’ Of course at your disposal is a laundry list of gadgets that you can purchase and upgrade to help you in your chosen play style as well. I generally prefer to play as a Ghost so sticky shockers and sleeping gas is the order of the day for me. You wanna blow shit up? Frag grenades for the assault guy. Essentially the gamer is being delivered the best sandbox style gameplay that this series has ever seen whether it’s the route you plan, the tools you use, or the tactics you employ.
One thing I’d like to point out, and to me this would be considered a flaw, is that the more Ghost-like you choose to play through a level the higher your cash bonuses are at the end of the level. The game implicitly gives the gamer the choice to purchase tools to go in on assault yet rewards them more for not doing so. If you’re telling a player that they have three options on completion it would seem fairer to reward them equally for all three. Yes, stealth, especially with no kills, is really hard but so is running into a plaza full of pissed off terrorists yelling, screaming and shooting things like you’ve got a stick of dynamite up your ass. In regards to buying upgrades and new tools it would seem as if the Assault style player has their hands full a bit more than the stealth players. Have fun replaying all those missions you murderous bastards!
I have to admit that I had a really hard time adjusting to playing this on the gamepad as opposed to a trusty 360 controller. It felt clunky and the differing button layouts always seem to confuse me whether I like it or not. In an effort to make it easier for me to navigate I switched to the pro controller and that definitely seemed to help. Unfortunately making that switch meant giving up the gamepad’s effective use as a weapon and gadget selection screen which is much more intuitive than pulling up a HUD. On top of that using the gamepad as a second screen motion control for sticky cams and peeking under doors is cool too. I didn’t want to give them up but I eventually got tired of having my ass handed to me just because I couldn’t get a handle on the controls.
A pleasant surprise for me was that the Wii U version of the game stacked up fairly well in comparison to its counterpart on the 360, which I took a look at as well, when it comes to the visuals department. Everyone knows that when it comes to pure graphical power the Wii U isn’t nearly on par with what we’ll be seeing from true next gen machines but as a cross comparison to current gen it still looked great. I actually noticed a lot less tearing in cutscenes on the Wii U than I did on the 360. I could have done without the ridiculous load times mind you but that to me always seems like such a petty gripe. If anything it just gives me time to grab another Cheeto for my fat ass.
Splinter Cell: Blacklist is hands down the most ambitious game in the series to date. Ubisoft Toronto made a very bold choice to try and appease fans of every past game we’ve seen and create a ‘Splinter Cell For All’ style game. By and large they’ve succeeded fairly well at their task. Sure there are a few minor hiccups and a little bit of adjusting to our new Sam Fisher but as it stands this is a great, if not one of the best, Splinter Cells we’ve seen.